In an English or literature class, we’re always asking questions—why did an author use a certain word? What is the significance of a particular color featured in the work, and what does it symbolize? How does the setting contribute to our understanding of the characters? In asking questions about a piece of writing, we not only uncover deeper meaning, we also see the importance of the piece of writing itself. That’s why asking questions as a peer reviewer is so critical to the reviewing process. As Best Peer Review winner for our Film/TV Series Review Competition Rosie Finley says, not only does peer review “challenge the [writer] to think deeply about how they can create meaning,” but it also shows them that their work is meaningful and deserving of thoughtful consideration. So next time you are giving a peer review, take a cue from Rosie and lead with questions!
We talk to Rosie about the rewards of peer reviewing, her short-term writing goals, and her favorite movie quote!
What’s your favorite thing about peer reviewing?
My favourite thing about peer-reviewing is being able to follow the journey of the writer. After providing constructive criticism, you are able to see how the writer adopts it, and how their piece develops over time. It’s always interesting to see how others will interpret your review, and how they mould your perceptions into choices. It’s a magical experience to be able to be a part of someone else’s writing journey!
We praised your review for making “the idea of a second draft feel not only possible but also exciting.” What tips do you have for other writers who want their reviews to achieve this?
It’s always easy to see what may seem “wrong” or out-of-place in a draft. And whilst it may be helpful to the writer to have this pointed out, it’s only useful when you encourage them to make personal choices as to how they want to adjust their piece. To me, peer reviewing is about (respectfully) questioning the writer—why did they choose that specific word? How can they delve further into analysis? These sorts of questions challenge the reader to think deeply about how they can create meaning, rather than just implementing changes stated by a reviewer.
What are your writing goals for the rest of the year?
As this year proceeds, I would love to continue sharing and reviewing on Write the World. Despite being new to the platform, I have seen tremendous changes in how I write and give feedback to others. One of my biggest goals is to write without dwelling too much on being “perfect.” I would love to write based on what inspires me, and hence, let my writing flow more naturally.
What’s your favorite movie quote?
There are too many to choose from! But as of right now, my favourite would be from a movie I adore that I rewatched recently.
“Writing doesn’t confer importance, It reflects It.” - Jo March, Little Women (film adaptation, 2019)
